Monday, December 07, 2015

Problems, pitfalls, and fallacies in Letter to Baghdadi by world Muslim scholars

This is an initiative by world Muslim scholars released the other day to combat ideologically and Islamically the record and understanding of ISIS.  This is the English version but I have read and am referring to the Arabic version.  Here are my concerns:
1) Notice a glaring omission: no Saudi clerics or religious scholars signed this letter. It is clear that the religious establishment in Saudi Arabia, which exercises undue influence due to wealth of the regime, has decided that it wants no part in this initiative.  Is this an appeasement of ISIS by the Saudi religious establishment or somethings else?
2) Some of the arguments are rather shallow: like to say that the ISIS folks don't have good understanding of Arabic.  As if the problem of ISIS is merely technical.  But their pointing out to Arabic grammar mistakes in speeches by ISIS is rather good.  The arrogant religious self-confidence of ISIS as well as their terrorist infrastructure should be shaken and dismantled.
3) Their point that verses or religious texts should not be taken out of context is well-taken but also applies to Western writers and pundits on Islam, especially those of the Islamophobe variety.
4) It is good that they remind ISIS kooks that most Muslim conversion in history was not by force (as older Orientalists used to maintain).
5) It is good that they remind them of imperssiblity of killing innocent people but they should have leaved that charge as well toward US, Russia and all Western forces fighting in Syria.  Furthermore, why have those religious scholars been silent about Arab regime's murder of innocent people? If they care about innocent lives they should have spoken earlier for us to believe their credibility.
6) On Jihad: that section bothers me. It begins by saying that all Muslims "see in Jihad a great virtue".  I am not sure that is true. There are many Muslims who see peace and prosperity and justice as greater in value than Jihad.  The section then proceeds to remind ISIS that there are two kind of Jihad's in Islam.  That is well-taken but they should have said the obvious: that ISIS and Western media and some Western experts basically have the same (mis)understanding of Jihad in Islam.  And rather than nullifying the notion of Jihad in the 21st century, the section asserts its relevance and then remind ISIS that Jihad against fellow Muslims is not permissible, thereby implying that Jihad against non-Muslims is still permissible.  The worst part is at the end of this section whey the religious scholars say: "Truthfully courage, willingness to sacrifice and intent to perform Jihad is seen in you, and no one--friend or foe--can deny that if sincere".  To imply the ancient tribal notion of courage about a bunch of terrorists defeats the whole purpose of this letter.  (Worse, the English version's translation is dishonest: they use the word "fearless" instead of "courage", which is in the Arabic original. And the section basically state that the signatories agree on the necessity of Jihad but disagree on the application by ISIS. This grants legitimacy for ISIS and other terrorists who kill in the name of Islam.
7) The letter condemns the killing of hostages and of Christians by ISIS but says nothing about the murder of Shi`ites and Alawites.
8) On page 14, they mention that they have distributed the books of Muhammad ibn `Abdul-Wahab but they don't say one way or another about that.
9) There is a section against Takfir but they don't seem to say a word about the takfir of Shi`ites and Alawites or of unbelievers. Where does those religious scholars stand on this?
10) The section on women is most weak and the signatories don't even dare say what their view is of the rights of women.
11) Section 21 is terrible: when they argue against rebelling against the rulers.  Here, the intention of the scholars is revealed: not so much to denounce and reject the terrorism of ISIS but to preserve the current regimes, many of which also practice terrorism.
12) 

Sunday, December 06, 2015

Racial profiling of Muslims

Was thinking: for those who argue for racial profiling of Muslims, do they know that there are some 1.6 billion Muslims in the world? How will you go about profiling them?

Obama's speech

Let me summarize Obama's speech: the US will continue to work with Saudi regime and its Wahhabi clerics to combat extremist Islam. Good luck.

My prediction about the rise of ISIS in the wake of US invasion of Iraq

I wrote yesterday about my former student, Neil Swidey of the Boston Globe. He reminded me of my words about the repercussions of US invasion of Iraq: " ''The Soviet occupation of Afghanistan gave us the Taliban,'' AbuKhalil says. ''The American occupation of Saudi Arabia gave us bin Laden and Al Qaeda. The Israeli occupation of Lebanon gave us Hezbollah. Let us see what the American occupation of Iraq is going to give us.''"

Syrian regime and progressive Islam

A Western correspondent asked me about my posts on progressive Islam at the time of Nasser:
"would you say the Syrian regime still promotes something that could be called progressive islam as in the time of nasser?"  My answer:  no, the Iraqi and Syrian Ba`th played games with Islam, sometimes (in 70s) promoting progressive Islam, and other times (late 80s and 90s) promoting their version of conservative Islam, and other times (Syrian regime after US invasion of Iraq) even promoting at time Jihadi Islam to use against the US but inconstantly.  The Syrian and Iraqi regimes were quite inconsistent: Hafidh Al-Asad for example related on his secular agenda after protests in Hamah and other places in 1973 regarding the new Syrian constitution and the presidential oath which originally didn't intend to mention God.  But the progressive religious agenda of the Ba`th in power was nothing like the consistent message of the Nasser regime, who even ridiculed clerics and even mocked those who want to veil their daughters.  But what I just wrote does not apply to the regime of Salah Jadid, who was an argent secularist and who allowed regime media to promote anti-religious agenda and got in trouble once the magazine of Jaysh Ash-Sha`b published this: "God and capitalism and feudalism have become embalmed idols in the museum of history".   Asad regime never went that far ever.  Furthermore, if you take Al-Buti who was the example of the so-called progressive Islam of the regime: he was never progressive in the sense of Mahmud Shaltut and other progressive senior clerics at Al-Azhar during Nasser's times.  Al-Buti is relatively progressive--in relation to the reactionary Islam of the various Qatari-supported or Saudi-supported or Turkish-supported Syrian rebels but he is by no means a progressive.  His book Kubra Al-Yaqinat Al-Kawniyyah is a rather reactionary book which attacks seculars and progressives in the most silly and vulgar way, and the regime sponsored the book and reissued many times.  (See about the non-progressive Buti the book by `Abdul-Razzaq `Id, Sadanat Hayakil Al-Wahm).  

Islamophobic Acts Since The Paris Attacks

"A Running List Of Shameful Islamophobic Acts Since The Paris Attacks"

An actual headline: "Germany rejects Germany's criticism of Saudi Arabia"

"The German government on Friday rejected the findings of a damning report on Saudi Arabia by its own spy agency and called Riyadh a key partner in regional conflict resolution". (thanks Basim)

Haytham Al-Manna`

Haytham is the founder of a human rights Arab organization: how could he attend the Syrian opposition meeting under Saudi regime auspices? 

Never trust Western leftist parties on foreign policy (or domestic policy for that matter):Jeremy Corbyn declares that his views on Palestine are those of George W. Bush

"Mr Corbyn said he remained committed to a “comprehensive peace in the Middle East based on a two-state solution, international law and a secure Israel alongside a secure and viable state of Palestine,” in line with Labour policy. " (thanks Nu`man)

Saudi media pin the blame for terrorism: leave it to a Lebanese advocate of House of Saud to pontificate

Writing in the mouthpiece of prince Khalid bin Sultan, Al-Hayat, this Lebanese advocate of House of Saud pontificates that leftist intellectuals are responsible for the phenomenon of Jihadi terrorism because they don't support the Saudi regime. Kid you not.

"U.S. shields its torturers & war criminals from prosecution, then honors them"

From a reader: "Yesterday, the U.S. government unambiguously signaled to the world that not only does it regard itself as entirely exempt from the laws of wars, the principal Nuremberg prohibition against aggressive invasions, and global prohibitions on torture (something that has been self-evident for many years), but believes that the official perpetrators should be honored and memorialized provided they engage in these crimes on behalf of the U.S. government."

US police officers are being tutored by Israel on how to employ the tactics that have brought death and serious injury to huge numbers of Palestinians

"US police officers are being tutored by Israel on how to employ the tactics that have brought death and serious injury to huge numbers of Palestinians in the past few months. Officers from 15 US police agencies recently traveled to the Middle East for lessons from their Israeli counterparts." "Since 1 October, Israeli forces have killed more than 100 Palestinians, including at least 19 children, in what human rights groups have labeled a “clear pattern” of summary executions." "A similar phenomenon is playing out in the US, where viral videos of police murders are the new normal,"

"Western arms dealers enjoy fueling wars in Syria & Yemen"

"Major defense contractors Raytheon, Oshkosh, and Lockheed Martin assured investors at a Credit Suisse conference in West Palm Beach this week that they stand to gain from the escalating conflicts in the Middle East." "And for “expendable” products, such as a rockets, Tanner added that there is increased demand, including from the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia because of the war in Yemen." (thanks Amir)

The FBI does not want to comment

"The F.B.I. said it did not yet have data for hate crimes in 2015, and would not comment on whether there had recently been a rise in attacks on Muslims and their houses of worship."

You read this sentence in passing and as an after thought in the article: Russia and ISIS

"Russia, which does not coordinate with the coalition, also has stepped up air raids in the Islamic State’s key oil-producing areas in eastern Syria."  Yet, Obama and other Western officials and media still insist that Russia only bombs "moderate" Syrian rebels.

Meet the leader of the moderate Syrian rebels

"Last July, an ultraconservative Islamist rebel group made a splash by publicly offering to work with Western powers to resolve the Syrian civil war and build “a moderate future,” a surprising overture from a force that regularly fights alongside al Qaida loyalists.
But the very next month, the same rebel group eulogized Mullah Mohammed Omar, the Taliban chief who sheltered Osama bin Laden before and after the 9/11 attacks, as a steadfast warrior who embodied “the true meanings of jihad and sincerity.”

Read more here: http://www.sacbee.com/news/article48061915.html#storylink=cpy"

Western governments and media and Aljazeera

When Aljazeera was dominated by secular Arab nationalists, Western governments and media were furious with the network.  But when the network fell under the influence of radical Islamists, Western governments and media became very pleased with it. True story.

Aljazeera Arabic: desperate

Aljazeera's decline throughout the Arab world has been steep and fast ever since the eruption of the first Arab uprising.  They are so desperate to recapture their past glory.  They are now reduced to airing videos about their secular anchor and how much they love Palestine.

A US official admits that Turkey buys oil from ISIS but says it is no big deal--KID YOU NOT

"""The amount of oil being smuggled is extremely low and has decreased over time and is of no significance from a volume perspective - both volume of oil and volume of revenue," said Amos Hochstein, US special envoy and coordinator for international energy affairs." (thanks Regan)

The New York Times wants Americans to spy on one another

"Unable to curb the availability of guns at home or extremist propaganda from overseas, the authorities may have to rely more on encouraging Americans to watch one another and report suspicions."

Converting to Islam or converting to Wahhabi fanaticism?

When Malcolm X, as he tells the story in his autobiography, became disenchanted with the corruption of Nation of Islam and when he discovered that the mainstream Islam in the Arab world was quite different from the messages of Nation of Islam he basically converted again to "mainstream" Islam--if there is such a thing.  At the time, Nasser's regime remodeled Al-Azhar and dare to fight the fanatical Wahhabi interpretation of Islam which was spread by the Saudi regime.  It was possible at the time for mosques in the West to follow the enlightened and progressive interpretations of Islam which were prevalent at Al-Azhar. When Sadat took over, he basically ended the reign of progressive Islam and allowed Saudi Arabia and the Muslim Brotherhood to surrender the Islam of Al-Azhar to the Wahhabi clerics.  There is no establishment progressive Islam permitted in the Arab world by order from Saudi Arabia.  Progressive clerics are either coopted or fought and marginalized.  Yet, Western governments rely on the Saudi regime to counter Jihadi messages with "moderation"--kid you not.

Saturday, December 05, 2015

Conversion to Islam: the horrific roles of the Saudi regime

Many of the Jihadi terrorists have been recent converts to Islam (25% of those who joined the ISIS terrorists in the Middle East).  This is something that can be addressed: those converts are "getting" those conversions in mosques funded AND equipped with religious books free of charge from the Saudi regime.  As a result, those converts are not really converting to mainstream Islam but to Wahhabi fanatical Islam.  No matter how much Western government feign outrage, all their efforts against Jihadis will be impaired due to their honeymoon alliance with the Saudi regime.  

Reforming Islam versus Reforming Catholicism

I thought about this while watching the movie, Spotlight, yesterday (about the sexual abuse scandal of the Catholic church).  I mean, the problem of sexual abuse within the church is rather institutional with corruption extending from the Popes down to the parishes and yet: no one ever called for reforming the Catholic religion because of this scandal.  In Islam, there are individual terrorists who commit terrorist act but never with any institutional cover or endorsement (but in Islam there are no real religious institutions per se because those institutions have been corrupt from their very brith and have been for sale from the very beginning).  It takes one act of terrorism by one Muslim or two for Westerners to insist that Islam needs to be reformed.  If you remember, Western colonialists wanted to reform Islam because of the acts of resistance back in the early 20th century--not to compare, of course, acts of resistance in the early 20th century with the dastardly acts of terrorism of the 21st century, but the comparison of Western reactions and motives still apply.

Neil Swidey of the Boston Globe

I could not be more happy with the success of Neil Swidey, a reporter for the Boston Globe and author of several books.  Neil was one of my first students ever, at Tufts University back in 1990.  What reminded me of him is watching the movie, Spotlight, about the Boston Globe.  Neil took two of my courses (Arab Politics and Arab-Israeli conflict) at the time and he was by far the very best student I had during my visiting stint at Tufts University.  I still remember his two research papers for my classes and how advanced his writing and analytical skills were.  This is one of the rewards of teaching: to follow the success of former students.

Lebanon negotiates with Al-Qa`idah

My weekly article in Al-Akhbar: "Lebanon Negotiates with Al-Qa`idah: "The Contract for the Formation of Nusrah Republic in `Irsal".

Friday, December 04, 2015

Syrian opposition in Riyadh

None of the people who write on Syrian affairs in US media bother with the stories of divisions and infighting in the ranks of Syrian opposition groups.  There has been intense conflicts over who should attend the meetings in Riyadh--the capital of the Syrian moderate and secular and feminist and hippie and Sufi and free-spirited opposition.  Michel Kilu was very hurt that his name was not submitted.  By secular feminist Islamist moderate war criminal, Zahran `Allush, made it into the list.

Your Western frustrations are over: this Lebanonese dude found 70,000 (the number is scientifically calculated) moderate Syrian rebels (and he interviewed them one by one)

Of course, the scandal is that the BBC would air this silly clip, just because it fits with the UK government position.  

The global and scientific influence of the American University of Beirut

"AUB FAFS graduate Dr. Jihad Douglas, joined President Obama on November 26, 2015, at the White House in pardoning the National Thanksgiving Turkey in his capacity as President of the American National Turkey Federation.
Dr. Douglas is the President of Aviagen Turkeys, the largest Turkey breeding company in the World. He received both his B.S. and M.S. degrees from AUB in 1982 and 1984, respectively, with a major in poultry nutrition under the supervision of Dean Emeritus Nuhad Daghir. He has an MBA from the University of Waterloo in Canada and a Ph.D. from the University of Nebraska. During the ceremony, President Obama thanked Dr. Douglas for all his contributions to the Turkey industry in the US and abroad. In a message sent to Dean Emeritus Daghir, Dr. Douglas concluded by saying “As always, my appreciation to your input and to AUB’s influence”." How could you not be proud?

Whatever happened to all those articles that Qasim Sulaymani was hit in Syria, and that he was either killed or injured?

Of course, Western media copied the fabrication of Saudi and Qatari regimes media.

CAIR and blaming all Muslims

From a reader: "If a Muslim is caught shoplifting, will CAIR hold a press conference?"  I responded: of course.

Siege of Ma`lula

From Sami: "I just came across this form the British MP Tom Tugendhat speech today - I dont know what his position back then was, but weren't most Western medias claiming that Ma'loula's siege was fabricated by the Syrian regime and that the rebels were innocent and should be given weapons? He apparently knew all along that it was ISIS:

Tom Tugendhat, a Conservative, gave a moving speech earlier in which he spoke of his knowledge of Syria. It was important to fight Isis, he said.
This is an enormously sad moment for me, I grew up as a young journalist in Lebanon spending my holidays in Syria. I know the country well and I love the people dearly - they gave me a kindness that no one else showed, they gave me a warmth and a richness of culture and history. It has been the most extraordinary sorrow for me to watch the destruction of Damascus, of Aleppo, of Homs and Hama, to see the Christians driven from Ma’loula, to see friends of mine, priests and monks driven from their monasteries and murdered.
And I know who is doing it, and we know who is doing it - yes, it is the Islamic State, the so-called Islamic State, this twisted perversion of Islam that is to Islam what fascism is to nationalism, that is to Islam what communism is to socialism. This vile, Stalinist death cult, this dreadful regime must, I’m sorry to say, be stopped, and sadly the only way to stop it is not through talks."

Saudi Arabia destabilizing Arab world

"Saudi Arabia is at risk of becoming a major destabilising influence in the Arab world, German intelligence has warned." "The overthrow of Syria’s president Bashar al-Assad remains a priority for the kingdom, the BND says. Saudi Arabia has previously been accused of supplying arms and funding to jihadist groups fighting in Syria, including Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (Isil)."

Who is expanding Al-Qa`dah's influence in Yemen?

"As Saudi Arabia’s allies try to bomb Islamic State out of its strongholds in Syria and Iraq, the kingdom’s war in Yemen is enabling jihadists to seize new ones. Al-Qaeda took over two cities in south Yemen on Wednesday, local media said." "The Houthis, the targets of Saudi anger after toppling a Gulf-backed government, have been effective fighters against jihadist groups in the past. As the rebels have been pushed back in southern Yemen, al-Qaeda-linked groups have taken control of territory, including the port of Mukalla in April. On Wednesday, the militants seized the cities of Zinjibar and Jaar in Abyan province, al-Masdar news website reported."

A question for Western journalism schools

Why do ALL Western correspondents in Beirut (or Cairo) all sound the same?  And write the same stories and have the same political perspectives--whether they are Republicans or Democrats?

When Israeli explosions kill civilians, Western correspondents in Beirut never notice

"Two citizens got slightly injured as a result of an explosion of an Israeli spy device on Tuesday afternoon on the main road of Marjeyoun Field, few kilometers away from the border at Al-Mtollah settlement, NNA reporter said. The spy device was remotely detonated, causing the injury of the two citizens who coincided to be working in the area which witnessed the blast."

Israeli soldier forces knife on 14-year-old, then arrest her

"A video has emerged apparently showing an Israeli soldier dropping a knife on the ground and forcing a terrified Palestinian girl to pick it up before she is arrested. The was video circulated widely in Palestinian media and on social networks on Tuesday, the same day that two more Palestinian teenagers were shot dead by Israeli occupation forces, who claimed that the youths had attempted to carry out stabbings."

FP cheers a warmonger Saudi prince

"The young prince has led the kingdom’s war against Iranian-backed forces in Yemen, proving that Riyadh is willing to sacrifice blood and treasure to drive Tehran’s influence from the Arab world." (thanks Basim)

this is only in passing by the way

"But the Arab armies have avoided attacking Al Qaeda, whose members have supported the fight against the Houthis."

Scandalous: Look how Reuters and New York Times absolve the Saudi regime of responsibility for the repression of women in the kingdom

"The rights of Saudi women are severely restricted by a powerful clergy and an ultraconservative society."  So it is the only the clergy and the society.  If only the feminist Saudi princes have their feminist ways all will be well.

Look how Palestinian casualties are ALWAYS listed as an afterthought in US media

"More than 20 Israelis and one American Jew have been killed in the uprising. Over 100 Palestinians have died in the same period".  Notice that Israelis are "killed" while Palestinians simply "die"--it must be natural causes.

Look how sensitive the state of Israel is

"Because they were minors at the time of the crime, the two Jewish teenagers’ names have not been made public".  When it comes to Palestinian toddlers, they immediately release their names and the names of their parents.

US versus Russian bombing of ISIS targets

"In the aftermath of the attacks in Paris this month, the United States has more aggressively targeted the militants’ oil production and smuggling operations, which it had held off from doing for fear of inflicting long-term damage to the Iraqi and Syrian economies. American aircraft this month struck a convoy of oil tanker trucks in eastern Syria, destroying 116 vehicles."  Russia in the same week announced that it destroyed more than 400 vehicles but that does not make it into US media.  

Look how mild US references are to Turkish assistance to ISIS

"Money-changing and transfer businesses in southern Turkey are another particular concern because they are believed to be helping the militants launder money, the European official said.  In a reflection of the growing frustration with Turkey, the State Department pointedly mentioned the use of the city of Gaziantep as a transit point for fighters heading to the Islamic State when it recently announced a $5 million reward for a senior militant figure."

Great discovery by Liz Sly

"Iraqis think the U.S. is in cahoots with the Islamic State".  This is not new or original.  This has been the common Arab view from day one.  Still most Arabs think that Bin Laden was an American creation and that he is still hidden by the US government.   And this is not only true about Iraqis.  There are false fabricated evidence being promoted: some insist that Hillary in her last book admitted that the US created ISIS, while others fabricate a quotation by Snowden to make the case.  Having said all that, it is indubitable that the US created the conditions that facilitated the rise of both: Al-Qa`idah and ISIS. Now that is not crazy at all.

So what is the Saudi official view of Ahrar Ash-Sham?

Well, it is complicated.