Emilie sent me everything I need to know about Michel Ofrey (I cite with her permission):
"I've just read your blog entry about Michel Onfray and as a French leftist, I have to react: Michel Onfray might have started off (a loooong time ago maybe ?) as a true anarchist, i.e. someone radically opposed to religion but also to any kind of social domination. That would have led him to criticize Islam as a religion but 1. not to become an atheist bigot looking at Islamic history and Muslims as vile or looking at Islam as more dangerous than any other religion, 2. to be able to analyze trends toward emancipation within Muslim social groups themselves and to be intelligent / knowledgeable enough about social movements to know that when we get on the path toward justice and fighting for radical equality, we all start from somewhere, and that somewhere doesn't have to be White, male, atheist, French and anarchist... I strongly believe that he uses the overall libertarian guise of "ni dieu ni maître" / "I dislike and criticize all religions" to actually specifically target Islam and Muslims. Or... a thought has just crossed my mind as I'm typing. Maybe, like some stupid anarchists I've heard, he actually says dumb, ignorant or racist things about all religions equitably, he's as uneducated about Christian or Jewish histories, and this time he happens to write about Islam ??? Who knows ? Either way, if he's an ignorant or dumb anarchist, to me the only part of it that sticks is the adjectives, not the "anarchist" part... I'm all for criticizing and mocking faith, religion, superstitions and rites in each and every variant of them. But I never find blanket statements like "Muslims are this" or "Islam is that [with no time frame or geographical reference or theological reference]" acceptable.
Long story short, here are links to a preface Onfray has recently written about Islam and then two leftist-anarchist websites that demolish the guy's imposture (and do so with arguments, mind you, not with the same kind of messy, sweeping generalizations as Onfray's).
1. Onfray's preface to an anti-Islam book:
Enjoy sentences like: "ce livre assassine l’idéologie islamique comme jamais encore." (what is "the islamic ideology" ??? Not islamist, no, really islamic !) and
"Critiquer l’islam, aujourd’hui, en France, relève du devoir pour tous les esprits libres et pour tous les révolutionnaires. (okay, phrasing is ambiguous, so I'll give him the benefit of the doubt and not assume that he meant specifically criticizing Islam compared to other religions...)
Comme le dit l’auteur, il faut appeler un chameau un chameau, et, donc, ceux qui adhèrent à l’amputation, à la circoncision, à la flagellation, au statut inhumain des femmes…, des obscurantistes religieux fascistes." (Ha ha ha, you have to call a camel a camel - the original is to call a cat a cat - because you, Islam, Arabs... well, the next image is camel, of course; nothing orientalist about that, right, because no anarchist could harbor orientalist prejudices, right ? And these last two sentence come straight one after another, making for nasty implications and generalizations, so here no benefit of the doubt !!!).
Once you read about the contents of the book he so praises (see last article I mention below), any ambiguity left will have been lifted about Onfray's racism.
The book in question was published by this house:
2. Now two critical views of Onfray by true leftist anarchists (e.g. they strongly opposed the exclusion of female students wearing a hijab from French public schools on anarchist grounds, i.e. "we still don't like religions, but it is totally sexist, classist and racist to exclude them, plus it is wrong to claim to emancipate people forcibly - people emancipate themselves through education, economic independence and common struggles, all things we deprive these women of when we exclude them from schools").
- Great website "Les mots sont importants" (search results for Onfray):
Key article on the issue you wrote about:
Full disclosure: I am acquainted with the two website owners (through common activism).
You should know that Onfray gets invited on mainstream TV quite a bit and seems to enjoy the attention. He is also very popular with anti-Muslim leftist movements, i.e. the failing, traditional left (and sadly traditional feminists who help defeat the Vatican and now think the next big threat is Islam...) in France (the article I suggest above deals with that:
- Funny anarchist columnist Sébastien Fontenelle in one of the last leftist weeklies with a readership of more that 3 people:
I copied the full blog post below.
By the way, your and his writing style and political ideology are very close, I think you would really like that guy's blog (he also likes to post pictures of "serious" people and make something funny out of it, like you !). He is great with ironical understatements and destructive flattery. His thing is also to mix everyday, sometimes rude language and old-sounding or very formal, very educated French to talk about current events, which makes the persons he attacks seem even more ridicule than they already are (case in point: instead of writing "Musulmans" for Muslims, he sometimes uses the weird, pre-20th century "Mahométans", which makes for hilarious effect and makes Sarkozy and the coward left sound like the backward colonialists they are).
Hope all this clarifies the Onfray thing..."
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query anarchist. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query anarchist. Sort by date Show all posts
Thursday, October 29, 2009
Saturday, August 20, 2005
Anarchism is NOT Comparable to Al-Qa`idah: I still consider the Economist the best magazine there is. Nothing comes close, not even US weekly. I wait for my issue with the same anticipation that I reserved for the arrival of Superman issues when I was a child. But while the Economist succeeds better than any US publication in keeping the opinions separate from the articles, sometimes "mistakes are made" as guilty US presidents always say. I just read the special report titled "For Jihadist, read anarchist" in the new issue. It was such a weak and failed argument, and the author(s) knew it, I felt. I cannot see how one can even compare the Bin Laden kooks with the Anarchist movement of the late 19th and early 20th century. First and foremost, Anarchism was notably an intellectual-philosophical movement, known more for its ideas (and later reputation). There is no intellectual movement behind the Bin Laden movement. You cannot name one intellectual guru for Al-Qa`idah--except Ibn Taymiyyah of course, and the writings of Dhawahiri are either tedious memoirs or rehashing of past Muslim writings. Anarchism was able to appeal to workers and intellectuals from around the world, regardless of religion, race, ethnicity, or nationality. Al-Qa`idah is a very narrow movement that appeals to a narrow segment of the fringe of the fringes of the Muslim fundamentalist movement. To be sure, there were acts of violence committed by Anarchist individuals (and not by some Anarchist Higher Power), just as there were acts of violence committed by individual adherents of every conceivable idea, religion, and movement. To strain the argument, given the difficulty of the task, the author of the article had to provide an anthology of Anarchist assassinations. But these were assassinations of public officials, and that should not be compared to the aimless and indiscriminate violence by Al-Qa`idah. Realizing that the argument was getting sillier and sillier, the author of the article then had to invoke the name of one Emile Henry who "had left a bomb in the cafe at the Gare ST.-Lazare." I never heard of Mr. Henry. That cannot pass as evidence. This was not the pattern of anarchist violence, as irregular but discriminate as it was. And instead of Mr. Henry, why not evaluate the works and career of the philosophical founders of the Anarchist thought. In that regard, I refer to the best source to date on that: Woodcock's classic Anarchism. He says on (on William Godwin): "Godwin stands with Tolstoy, and to an extent with Proudhon, among those who place more persuasion and passive resistance above violent and active resistance. He does not actually deny active resistance. But he counsels extreme caution in its use. Force is no substitute for reason, and its use by people who seek to establish justice does not make it any better. It should never be used without the prospect of success, and even then only "where time can by no means be gained, and the consequences instantly to ensue are unquestionably fatal." Violence, then, is the last, desperate resort of just men." (p. 79). And you think that these opinions are comparable to those of Bin Laden? And when the Economist talks about Bakunin they descend to the level of street and police stereotypes about Anarchists and Anarchism. They, of course, had to cite Bakunin's "the passion for destruction is also a creative urge." Bakunin was certainly not talking about destroying buildings. He wrote that line early in his anarchist career when he fell under the influence of the Young Hegelian Arnold Ruge. Bakunin, after Ruge, was standing Hegel's dialectics on its head, and demonstrating that this dialectics can show that Revolution is real, and that radical change is continuous. In that very important essay where that line is found he also describes his utopia as: "There will be a qualitative transformation, a new living, life-giving revelation, a new heaven and a new earth, a young and mighty world in which all our present dissonances will be resolved into a harmonious whole." And you wish to compare that to Al-Qa`idhah's threatening and fanatically dogmatic brochures and manuals? Can the author of that article argue that Anarchism, or even anarchists because movements do not act by themselves they need men and women to carry them over, was responsible for more violence than say Western democracies or Socialist Soviet-style governments? If anything, it can be argued that as we enter a new century, we can look back and see how prophetic (don't like that word) anarchists were because they were the early voice of critique and dissent against Soviet-Marxism-Leninism (and even orthodox Marxism prior to that, real Paul Thomas on that), and yet they never wavered in their critique of capitalism. If anything, the world owes a debt to Anarchism because of its principled opposition to the main sources of injustice in the 20th century, in the state and in society. Anarchism did not have false prophets or gods, and they never struck lousy alliances. They never bet on the wrong horse, because they do not bet on horses, and don't bet at all. I think that you can say that Al-Qa`idah is comparable to any fanatical movement or regime that absolutely disregards civilian lives, and in that the comparison to Anarchism was fallacious and simply sensational. I think that we can compare the specter of Anarchism that haunted Western governments in the 19th century and early 20th century, with the current specter of Islamist fanatical violence haunting Western governments. But that does not prove that Anarchism and Al-Qa`idah are thus comparable, unless one has no exposure to the introductory basics of logic. But I can compare the movement of Al-Qa`idah with the nihilism of Sergei Nechaev. That analogy I accept, and Nechaev was no Anarchist.
Tuesday, January 31, 2017
Six other times the US has banned immigrants
"3. Anarchists banned
President Theodore Roosevelt. Signed on March 3, 1903. In 1903, the Anarchist Exclusion Act banned anarchists and others deemed to be political extremists from entering the US. In 1901, President William McKinley had been fatally shot by Leon Czolgosz, an American anarchist who was the son of Polish immigrants. The act - which was also known as the Immigration Act of 1903 - codified previous immigration law and, in addition to anarchists, added three other new classes of people who would be banned from entry: those with epilepsy, beggars and importers of prostitutes. The act marked the first time that individuals were banned for their political beliefs."
Thursday, May 15, 2008
"I am an anarchist, and according to anarchist principles nation states become obstacles to a true humanistic globalization. In a certain sense the movement towards globalization where capitalists are trying to leap over nation state barriers, creates a kind of opportunity for movement to ignore national barriers, and to bring people together globally, across national lines in opposition to globalization of capital, to create globalization of people, opposed to traditional notion of globalization." (thanks Kathy)
Sunday, December 01, 2013
The first American Anarchist
It is agreed that the first American anarchist was Josiah Warren. But the last biography of the man was written in 1906.
Monday, February 20, 2012
Anarchist take
As somebody with anarchist leanings, I can never for the life of me be sympathetic to a regime offensive against anybody in society--even if they are reactionary groups that I detest, particularly if the regime in question is a lousy regime with which I share no ideology or goals.
Tuesday, February 28, 2006
My ode to Brezhnev. Leonid Brezhnev, I must confess that I miss you. While I was growing up, I sympathized with the Soviet side during the Cold War. And then I discovered Kronstadt and the Anarchist criticisms of Soviet communism (and Marcuse's critique), and I became disillusioned with the Soviet Union too. And you read about Stalin, but then you could say (at least back then) that the Soviet Union has changed. But I still never could really like the Soviet Union: did not like the rhetoric, and particularly resented the special supermarket that was reserved for members of the Politburo. I agree with the early Anarchist criticisms of the Soviet Union: that we can trace Stalin in Lenin (and some say and trace Lenin in Marx--of the latter I am less certain these days, perhaps because of ideological nostalgia in the Age of Bush--and Clinton). And I never liked Soviet foreign policy: how they pushed for Arab regonition of Israel, how they gave Arabs their worse weapons, how they misled the Arabs, but they also aided Arab countries, although those regimes sqandered aid, or utilized them for lousy policies (the Ba`th for example). And I look now: you see the UN: how it became a mere tool for US. There was a UN during the Cold War: neither the US nor the Soviet Union could get their way back then. And there was no Kofi Annan back then, and Hariri cult did not exist. If I only can bring back the Cold War, and I would if I can revive Brezhnev. Would that be insensitive to Russian people? Not really. I was reading the approval ratings of STALIN: that muse be due to their disillusionment with "democracy" and "capitalism". During the Cold War, Harvard economists could not exploit Russian economy for their own benefit and profit.
Friday, February 24, 2006
"Paul Avrich, a historian of the anarchist movement that played a role in the Russian Revolution and flourished in America in the 19th and early 20th centuries, died on Feb. 16 at Mount Sinai Hospital. He was 74 and lived in Manhattan....The subjects of his books included the Kronstadt naval base rebellion of 1921, an uprising of sailors against the Bolshevik regime that left more than 10,000 dead or wounded; the Haymarket Riot of 1886, in which seven Chicago police officers were killed by a bomb thrown at a workers' gathering; and the Sacco and Vanzetti case. He interviewed hundreds of adherents of the movement for one book, "Anarchist Voices: An Oral History of Anarchism in America.""
I was most sad to wake up to the news of Avrich's death. I first discovered Avrich while an undergraduate student at the American University of Beirut. I was at the time going through my disillusionment with Marxism-Leninism and developed an obsession with the Kronstadt Rebellion. At the time, I was going to specialize in Soviet studies (which remained my minor even in graduate school here in the US). I was collecting every bit of information that I could find on the rebellion. I wrote a letter to Abrich, and received a very kind response and he showed interest and expressed encouragement. I wanted to write my MA thesis on Kronstadt. My interests continued, but my advisor at the time (Rashid Khalidi) explained that we did not have the resources at the university (in terms of Russian language training) for me to earn a MA in Soviet Studies, and that I needed Russian for the research. Hanna Batatu (who was on sabbatical in the US at the time) agreed in a letter (Batatu had studied Russian in the US). I will today (or tomorrow) reread Avrich's book on Kronstadt.
I was most sad to wake up to the news of Avrich's death. I first discovered Avrich while an undergraduate student at the American University of Beirut. I was at the time going through my disillusionment with Marxism-Leninism and developed an obsession with the Kronstadt Rebellion. At the time, I was going to specialize in Soviet studies (which remained my minor even in graduate school here in the US). I was collecting every bit of information that I could find on the rebellion. I wrote a letter to Abrich, and received a very kind response and he showed interest and expressed encouragement. I wanted to write my MA thesis on Kronstadt. My interests continued, but my advisor at the time (Rashid Khalidi) explained that we did not have the resources at the university (in terms of Russian language training) for me to earn a MA in Soviet Studies, and that I needed Russian for the research. Hanna Batatu (who was on sabbatical in the US at the time) agreed in a letter (Batatu had studied Russian in the US). I will today (or tomorrow) reread Avrich's book on Kronstadt.
Monday, July 25, 2005
"Islamo-Anarcs or Islamo-Fascists?" (Neither of the label is accurate. We don't have a mass movement that is comparable to European fascist movements. And they (the Bin Ladenite fanatics) certainly are not anarchist or anarchistic even. These people want to establish a strong and dominating state that is rigidly based on their narrow and strict interpretation of religious laws. How is that anarchist? I wish that Tariq Ali would stop using the term "Islamo-anarchists" while Christopher Hitchens keeps using the term "Islamo-fascists". These religious fanatics don't even deserve to be called "Islamo." Do we apply the term "Christiano" or "Jewisho" to terrorists using Christianity or Judaism for their own ends? No.)
Wednesday, October 05, 2016
Being a Marxist or Anarchist Professor in the US
I was talking to a Marxist colleague here on campus. We said that if were teaching in the US back in the 1940s or 1950s, we would have been harassed and persecuted and probably jailed, but that ironically you are safe to be a Marxist in the US these days when the enemy are Islamists. I told him: if I have the same views I have, and I write exactly what I write on my blog but if I were a religious Muslim, things would have been different for me, and that I would have been persecuted. Bottom line: it is safe to be a Marxist in the US (now), and it was safe to be a conservative Muslim in the US (back in the 1950s when the Muslim Brothers were tools of US foreign policy against communists).
Thursday, March 14, 2013
"French trotskyists on Syria": dreaming
From Adam: "Hello As'ad,
I wish to link to that
silly analysis on the Syrian situation. It is a ridiculous attempt by French
Troskyists to depict the uprising in Syria as a revolutionnary model for
leftists.
"Une
dynamique d'auto-organisation
Ces
menaces ont pour objectif d’empêcher un changement radical auto-organisé par le
peuple révolutionnaire. Celui-ci a développé les expériences des comités
populaires au niveau des villages, quartiers, villes et régions. Ils sont la
colonne vertébrale du mouvement et de la résistance, allant de l’organisation
des manifestations, de l’aide humanitaire, de l’accueil des réfugiés, à la
formation scolaire des enfants et adolescentEs. Dans les régions libérées, ils
sont en charge des services à la population. En coordination avec la résistance
armée, ils sont à la base de la résistance populaire. "
When
you read that, you are under the impression that the uprising in Syria is an
anarchist one. And the author assumes that islamist extremists have no links
with the FSA. In one word : dumb."
Monday, February 08, 2010
The most dubious of honors: or the least honorable mention ever
What do you do when you are mentioned in the blog of the worst writer on the Middle East in the entire world? I mean, that. You need to research this website and see what I have written about this man: Jeffrey Goldberg, who proudly served in the Israeli occupation forces. The man was an occupation jailer of the inhabitants and owners of the land of Palestine. I have mocked the writings of this man for years: because you can't take seriously what he writes. This is a man who traveled to the Middle East in the wake of Sept. 11 to talk to "Muslims." He was peddling the theory that Muslims engage in suicide bombings because they seek sex in the hereafter. I still remember the lousy article that he wrote for the New Yorker in which Islamist lawyer, Muntasir Az-Zayyat, had to shock Goldberg by telling him to his face: well, you know that Muslims do engage in sex here on earth (or words to that effect). It was clear that Goldberg had no clue and no idea. He was shocked to discover that Muslims have sex on earth. It just never occurred to him. You can take the good book on suicide bombings by Robert Pape, Dying to Win, as a documented to rebuttal to the dumb Israeli-peddled theories on the subject. Goldberg today said this: "He bases this on complaints from, among others, something called "The Angry Arab News Service." Hoyt writes: "Web sites like the Angry Arab News Service have called him a propagandist for Israel." Did it strike Hoyt that perhaps a web site called "The Angry Arab News Service" might be engaged in the dissemination of, you know, propaganda? " There is an old Arabic saying by `Ali Bin Abi Talib in Nahju Al-Balaghah which says: I have never argued with a reasonable man and did not defeat him, but I never argued with an ignorant man who did not defeat me. So I would in no way argue with somebody whose Middle East training amounts to training in the Israeli occupation army. As for the charge of zealotry: I stand guilty. I am a zealot when it comes to secularism, women's right, reason, the belief in sciences and not quackery, the belief in the abolishment of capitalism and the end of poverty, the principled opposition to Zionism in all its deadly forms (paper forms or land forms), the belief in the goal of liberating all of Palestine and the return of all Palestinian refugees to their homes, the belief in socialism and in anarchist critiques of the state--the state in itself. On all those principles I am a zealot--proudly. With somebody who volunteered in an occupation army and who served as a jailer for the natives of the land, there should be no arguments. Trials would be in order, not arguments. (thanks Olivia)
Sunday, December 06, 2009
The Arabs
I just ordered Eugene Rogan's The Arabs. I love those sweeping history books on the history of the Arabs. But I am critical, as you know by now. I remember when Albert Hourani was spending time at Dartmouth one semester, and he came down to Georgetown and told us about his plans for an upcoming book on the history of the Arabs. I was most excited: especially that he told us about the failings--in his eyes--of Philip Hitti's History of the Arabs. He was right in pointing out that Hitti merely considered the Ottoman Empire to be the "dark ages", unworthy of investigation for Hitti. But when Hourani's book came out, I was most disappointed. It is probably the least impressive book by Hourani. He has nothing new and it is not as well-written as Hitti's, for sure. The book seems rushed and even casually assembled together. Even the bibliography was hastily collected together, I felt, and the massive work of Abu Al-Faraj Al-Asfahani was not correctly identified, I remember. Personally, I prefer Ira Lapidus's A History of Islamic Societies. It is more like an encyclopedia and I realized that it is considered torturous by students but there is so much work in that book, and I enjoy reading it. But it does not cohere thematically, I admit. There is a short book on the Arabs by my favorite Orientalist, Maxime Rodinson, and another one (larger) by Jacques Berque (the Arabs: their history and future). And don't forget the book by Carl Brockelmann, History of the Islamic Peoples. I remember that the man who introduced the book to me when I was in college (it was the intensely eccentric Palestinian anarchist, George Jad`, who had an influence on our small radical group back then) told me about it: it is historical materialism without the knowledge of the author. But personally, I really like Philip Hitti's, with all its flaws, methodologically and politically. I love reading and re-reading that book. I recommend that book to everyone. I mean the combination of details and sweeping conclusion reminds one of Braudel. There is a scene in that book about life during the Abbasid time and he descibes what they served in those lavish dinner. I remember when dinner guests once wondered why the fish on their plates seemed small, unlike the lavishness of food in those banquets, only to be told that they were being served the tongues of rare fish. I can go on and on. Let me confess to an unPC hobby: I really enjoy reading the works of classical Orientalists. The erudition, knowledge, language skills, meticulousness, originality, and scope of research are a delight to the reader. Of course, this is no place to go over the obvious political and methodological problems of Orientalists. But between reading, say Fouad Ajami or post-1970 Bernard Lewis or Elie Kedourie or Efraim Karsh and any classical Orientalist, I take a classical Orientalist ANY DAY of the week.
Thursday, October 07, 2010
Even "anarchists" in the Zionist entity are racists
"James Horrox’s book on anarchism in the kibbutz movement marginalises the Palestinian people in a similar way – they do not really exist in his narrative of how the Israeli collective settlements were established and then functioned. He is writing about Palestine, a country whose population was around 90% Arab (Christian and Muslim) when the first kibbutz was established in 1910, as if its primary importance was as a plaything for European experiments in group living [2]. The book is a strange attempt to blend Zionist mythology with anarchism. In the forward, Israeli anarchist Uri Gordon questions "the validity of applying anti-colonial hindsight to people that any progressive would otherwise consider economic migrants or refugees" (p. iv)." (thanks Asa)
Sunday, August 03, 2008
Thursday, November 20, 2014
Mike Nichols: dead
"his grandfather, Gustav Landauer, was a political anarchist leader who was killed by right-wing opponents in 1919."
Tuesday, September 17, 2013
my anarchism
I often get asked about my anarchism but rarely wrote about it. I started as individual anarchist (along the lines of Max Stirner's The Ego and Its Own but gradually moved toward Russian-style communism anarchism over the years.
Monday, July 18, 2016
First use of car bombs and truck dumbs
It is established that the first person to ever use a car bomb was the AMERICAN anarchist Mario Badu, in the wake of the arrest of Sacco and Vanzetti. He left it off on Wall Street in 1920. But the real indiscriminate and random use of truck bombs and car bombs was really pioneered in the 1940s in Palestine by the Stern Gang. As always, it has to be remembered that Zionist gangs in Palestine were the early pioneers of the first uses of terrorist tactics and methods (car bombs, letter bombs, bombs on busses, bombs in markets and stores, bombs in ambulances, letter bombs, barrel bombs). ISIS and Al-Qa`idah should really acknowledge their debt to Zionist gangs.
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
The Full text of the Home Office's Report on "Islamic blogs"
How ignorant are the researchers of the Home Office? How many time does one have to espouse atheist, anarchist, and secular principles before they realize that their categorization is screwed up? Or did they categorize the blogs on the basis of the names of the bloggers? I really suspect it was the latter. How else would you explain the addition of my blog to their list of "Islamic blog."
Tuesday, February 18, 2014
Unsi Al-Hajj, dead
Lebanese poet, Unsi Al-Hajj, died today. He has been ill for a while. I never thought that I would get along with him ever until I met him several years ago. He came from An-Nahar newspaper, which as you know I abhor. Al-Hajj was active in the journal "Shi`r", which leftist and Arab nationalists opposed. I have some of the old issues and some are valuable but I disagreed with the outlook and purpose. Al-Hajj later edited the Culture Supplement of An-Nahar in the 1960s and 1070s (until the civil war) and it was a great success. He started the supplement at an early age and succeeded in injecting it with some liberal progressive thought in a newspaper that was and is reactionary, through and through. I can't lie and say that I was a consumer of his poetry: my literary preferences are rather more classical and perhaps conservative in Arab poetry. I am told that Al-Hajj never read me (although we wrote in the same paper and our articles both appeared on Saturday) until sometime in 2008 when I wrote a scathing critique of his friend, Joumana Haddad. He became a strong supporter and in fact edited and corrected my articles weekly. My colleague Khalid Saghiyyah told me that when he heard Unsi's laugh it meant that he was reading my article. I met him several times during my rare visits to Lebanon. He is very nice and sociable and easy to get along with. He did not carry himself like the obnoxious Lebanese journalists of his generation (or even of all generations). His door was always open and loved the company of young female reporters. I used to ask him about his experience at An-Nahar and about the Rahbani brothers and he was most forthcoming and candid but did not want me to write about his answer during his lifetime. He told me that he used to write the articles that appeared with Jubran Tuwayni's name in An-Nahar Al-`Arabi wa-d-Duwali and that Ghassan Tuwayni would call him and urge him to make some grammatical mistakes in order that people believe that Jubran was indeed the author. He told me about his big salary at An-Nahar and that it was quite tempting to stay there but that he could not stomach the political views of Jubran Tuwayni and he left to protest the stance of An-Nahar toward the American invasion of Iraq in 2003. He told me about the foreign financing of An-Nahar about about briefcases of cash from Kuwait--a typical story about Arab newspapers, of course. He was not a leftist by any means but he told me that he disagreed with the right-wing Phalange views of his father, Luwis (a brilliant editor of An-Nahar in the 1960s and 1970s), who revealed his own true colors in his really revealing book, Min Makhzun Adh-Dhakirah. I would ask him a lot about the Rahbani brothers and he confirmed to me that indeed Mansur's role was marginal and that `Asi would call on Mansur in his presence and say: Mansur. Here, take this poem and make me a song. I need it this week. He was into astrology (which bores me to death as interesting as he was) and would ask me about my sign. When he sensed my disregard, he protested: I don't follow astrology like the common people but purely the scientific version of astrology based on the movement of the stars. In one of this last columns, he wrote about people he met in life under the title "Intimacy". I was rather surprised that he mentioned me but never understood what he meant: "As`ad AbuKhalil, the anarchist, fortunately".
أسعد أبو خليل الفوضوي لحسن الحظّ.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)